“If there was anything seriously in it, why over the centuries has not every gardener or, more importantly, every horticulturalist, followed these maxims? and one core clock gene.” Which would relate to waxing and waning and how different plants my respond to either. “However, in artificial conditions, Does Companion Planting Work? But not everything has changed. Why not try an experiment – take 2 identical healthy plants and plant one when the moon is full and the gravitational pull is strongest. But plants do have circadian rhythms, internal 24 hour clocks. Love fresh tomatoes for Thanking diner. It also affects everything else on earth, but, and it is a big but, the effect on most things is so small we can’t see it and in many cases can’t even measure it. Its been a week since I posted. Every drop of water is a benediction. I consider the results of my experiment scientific proof, that a full moon promotes plant growth. Maybe, the effects of gravity, with full moons etc, have a negative effect on plants. My flashlight is tied to my garden hat, with new batteries freshly inserted. If you are planting a plant for what you don’t see, root/ bulb/ tuber plant it when the moon is not visible or at a … Planting crops according to the moon’s phases is almost older than dirt – a concept older than the Farmer’s Almanac itself. My seed of choice is beets. Other legitimate scientific sites say that there has been no real research on the moon’s effect on plants. the Jury is still out with me. Regardless of which system you follow, the whole essence of Moon planting is that, depending on the crop, there are only a few ideal days each month in which to plant. Man has come up with many crazy theories about the moon and none are true, not even werewolves. The lunar experts suggest that you pick fruit at the full moon for the market as it will weigh more and pick at the new moon for personal consumption because the fruit stores better. Often there's another reason a crop fails but sometimes it was the "wrong" sign. My grandfather always planted by the moon. We always plant by the moon. Not only does the gravitational pull of the moon affect the tides & rainfall, but it affects the air currents on the surface of the earth as well. It is also a good time to weed and take care of pests. The tray on the left was sown during Full Moon phase, which is an incorrect moon planting phase for leafy annuals. That same gravitational pull can help a plant lift water up its stem. In this system it is believed that sidereal moon signs are more important than tropical moon signs – whatever they are? Plants will have developed to deal with direct sunlight, since it is far more prevalent. Other contradictory views exist. There is scientific evidence that moon light does affect plants. However, there is some real scienceto this gardening method. Glad to see you took on this common myth. Global warming has thrown that out of whack, but I wanted to see how well the phases of the moon correlated with this date. I will get the first batch going this weekend. It makes sense to consider when planting your garden, the pull of the moon (sic). The extra light can affect plants directly, and insects feeding on plants are also affected. All it’s energy will be pulled out to the leaves away from the roots. Then using your moon calendar for best planting time- plant the twin when all the energy and goodness has gone back down to its roots. But their system is external and controlled by the environment. My moon planting life began in April. Even if the moon had some small affect on plants the weather during and for a few weeks after planting has a much larger affect on the success of that crop. So you plant crops or pick grapes during the waxing (increasing) phase, and harvest crops or cut timber during the waning phase. But this is what I can prove…I learned years ago that you can start new willow trees to grow by clipping stems off an existing willow tree, and sticking them in dirt while keeping them soaked in water, until new buds start sprouting all over the place. wait. I’m sure garden centers love those people if it means more sales. I do know some people who swear by moon phase planting. So, even the light is of a different make up. When I sow seed I use 198 cell seeding trays so I can count exactly how many seeds germinate. Strangely enough I have a different story to tell. I practice no-till gardening, and every time I plant transplants, I spit into the hole before sticking the roots in it. I have my garden tools set up in the space I am going to plant, and the smaller tools are secured in my garden apron. That is my scientific research experiment regarding the power of the full moon and it’s effects on plant growth. “Well, lass, it works for me.” He said, as he handed me a round tin of Copenhagen chewing tobacco. In my area the last frost date has always been around May 24. In my area, to this day radishes usually come in during May, strawberries arrive in June, raspberries in July, corn and tomatoes in August and September. I have this idea that I can establish a positive microbial feedback loop between the garden and me, whereby we both develop a complex, diverse, resilient microbiome that enables us to thrive. Dozens of people castrated me for not being a believer. I can’t prove it, but there is something magic about willow trees besides the Salicin in the willow that cures headaches and takes away pain so much faster than Bayer aspirin. That said, I’m the kind of person who listens but I will find out for myself, not just blindly take someone else’s word for it. The moon has four basic phases which last about seven days each. I checked everything temperature, weather, did I change my mix etc and I could not find an answer. In the first two quarters, the ‘new’ dark moon you see gets bigger and more visible. You can get a 10 year ephemeris for $10 or so. I learned about this from 2 professional veterans who I trust. Thank you! We're not quite sure, but the Wizard of Oz never looked so groovy to us before now. In 2003, Which? I don’t see anything in this study that shows planting by the moon has any effect on plants. Really? Ohh and explain how it pulls “energy” from the roots and how it got in the roots in the first place. He found that in lab studies, plants absorbed more water during the full moon. Sounds like a plan. After 7, 14 and 21 days, from the start date of each batch of cuttings, count the number with new buds. Lunar planting is your own personal organiser but, as far as we can see, it does not actually have anything to do with the moon’s gravitational pull. Wow, strong words…chastised maybe? They love to be the discoverer of a new myth, or the breaker of an old myth. In addition, some seeds, such as lettuce, germinate better when they're exposed to light, so planting during the full moon could, in theory, enhance germination. To make moon planting really simple, when the moon is a new moon, this is not the time to plant anything. Making your own simple and inexpensive homemade fertilizers can be…, How to Germinate Peach Pits (and Why You Should), Discover how to germinate peach pits and save money by…, 12 Uses for Rose Petals — From the Kitchen to the…, Explore the wondrous powers of the rose—from relieving sore throats…. It was a very entertaining read! Robert: Another well-researched analysis that debunks a gardening myth. There will, however always be a little bit in back of my mind, nagging me. I realize that a person does not really have to plant in the dark, but I am determined to get as close to the wane as possible. We don’t always stick to the guidelines, but we do when it’s convenient. First, lunar gardeners believe the moon's gravitational pull affects the flow of moisture in the soil. So in the UK, which is mostly zone 8, you should plant beans a week later than here in my zone 5 garden! Thanks for the article! There is a strong possibility that the phases of the moon affect plant growth. But as any gardener/ farmer would tell you, plans are nice and helpful but life happens……:), Hi, I don’t really believe in planting by the moon, but I found an FA Brown study similar to that you mentioned. I have come to appreciate the older gardeners that live in my locale. Some of which we can control in some amount or other. My conclusion is if it worked for you, fine. Honestly, I think that if you have healthy, active, nutritious soil – the moon is really an afterthought. “MONTHLY CYCLES IN AN ORGANISM IN CONSTANT CONDITIONS DURING 1956 AND 1957”. Old timers, of which I am now considered one, have a lot of history with this good earth . I planted by the Biodyndamic calendar for my first round crops this year. Gardening by the Moon is a great way to plan your garden. At some point in the future, I may try all three moon planting ideas, but on this night I am working only with the synodic waxing and waning cycle. That is a nice offer on your part Robert..thank you. All of the beets in my garden, regardless of planting time, tasted sweet and bled red. (Beginner) I am a curious and skeptical individual who often debates with people who believe in planting vegtable gardens by the signs of the zodiac and the phases of the moon. The light from the moon already came from the sun, so I don’t personally consider that a factor, just makes it easier to see at night sometimes. I recently visited the Organic Conference in Guelph Ontario and looked at some Moon Calendar Books. “Also, with alternative theories, why do the effects of these things always have to be thought of as positive. Planting by the Moon; Planting by the Moon. I got the date of the full moon that was closest to May 24, for each year between 2000 and 2020 (ref 6). Hello plant people. Simply put, Planting by the Moon (also called Gardening by the Moon or Moon Phase Gardening) is the idea that the lunar cycle affects plant growth. Alongside the moon rows, I had planted several rows of beets when the moon chart clearly said, DO NOT PLANT ROOT CROPS AT THIS TIME.